Doctor Who‘s Animated Adventure Fell a Little Flat

Doctor Who‘s had a bigger fund successful the past fewer years than it’s arguably ever had acknowledgment to the BBC’s team-up with Disney, and with that has travel the capableness for immoderate truly large ideas delivered with a glitz and glam the amusement could lone different have dreamed of. This week, “Lux” sees an unthinkable Doctor Who thought that could arguably lone beryllium champion executed with this benignant of fiscal backing… truthful it’s unfortunate that that thought is heaped nether a chaotic tonal mess.

“Lux” is mostly acceptable successful 1952 Miami, wherever the Doctor and his reluctant companion Belinda find themselves shunted to erstwhile the Doctor tries to find a mode astir the TARDIS’ unwillingness to instrumentality to modern Earth. Of course, arsenic with immoderate good Doctor Who story, their accomplishment is conveniently timed: they onshore close connected the doorstep of a locked up cinema, a determination wherever a radical of moviegoers mysteriously vanished months prior, amid claims that the cinema is present haunted arsenic its caretaker inactive plays the movies each night.

Before the Doctor and Belinda get their ain probe underway—with a small amusive propulsion and propulsion betwixt the duo arsenic Belinda, anxious to get home, relents to the Doctor’s accustomed curiosity—we’ve already learned that the crushed for the disappearance. It’s the prima of “Lux,” the mysterious Mr. Ring-a-Ding (played by the delightful arsenic ever Alan Cumming, successful a precise antithetic code from his turn arsenic King James successful “The Witchfinders”). A classical cartoon quality from the movie pre-show reels magically brought to beingness by the airy of the moon, Mr. Ring-a-Ding hasn’t conscionable gained consciousness of his animated existence, but been suffused with the powerfulness of the mysterious pantheon that has been haunting the Doctor ever since the 60th day specials: and also, the powerfulness of a fully-armed-and-operational Disney-backed budget.

© BBC/Disney

Mr. Ring-a-Ding looks incredible. Who makes afloat usage of conscionable however overmuch it wants to amusement that it tin propulsion disconnected this 2D quality successful a existent abstraction with plentifulness of panning and tracking shots that are tons of fun. It lone gets amended erstwhile the Doctor and Belinda brushwood him up close, whipping astir truthful we tin spot conscionable however good, and intentionally discordant helium looks successful the existent world. He is much than conscionable razzle and dazzle too—Cumming embodies Ring-a-Ding with a delectable menace, a creepy, vindictive grotesquery that instantly begins utilizing his godlike powers to play with the cloth of the world, and the occurrence itself. It is such a shame past that erstwhile helium truly begins doing truthful is erstwhile “Lux” goes a small spot excessively chaotic for its ain good.

Once Ring-a-Ding catches up with the Doctor and Belinda, and zaps them into his erstwhile location down the screen, “Lux” conscionable starts flinging thought aft thought astatine you and ne'er giving galore of them clip to descend in. First, the Doctor and Belinda find that they’ve been flattened into animated beings, and person to flight by admitting fears and insecurities that dilatory springiness them literal and communicative extent until they instrumentality to mean (ironically, somehow, this process ends up looking worse than thing the occurrence does with Mr. Ring-a-Ding). Then, suddenly, they’re physically yanking themselves done strips of movie reel to effort and interruption done the screen. Then they deliberation they’ve made it out, lone to beryllium confronted by a faux-reality that comes with a side-order of the specter of Temporal Racism that’s brushed implicit arsenic rapidly arsenic it is brought up.

© BBC/Disney

And then, conscionable arsenic suddenly, they find themselves falling retired of the TV of a radical of Doctor Who fans, realizing that they themselves, contempt protestations, are characters successful an occurrence of a TV show. This 1 is admittedly brilliant—it could prolong a full occurrence successful and of itself, and Russell T Davies is intelligibly having a hoot penning 1 meta gag astir Whovians aft the other. But past it has to go an overwrought affectional existential situation erstwhile the Who fans recognize they’re going to popular retired of meta-narrative beingness astir arsenic soon arsenic they get connected screen, conscionable successful clip for the Doctor and Belinda to get back, get captured by Ring-a-Ding again, and past decision him by fundamentally suffusing him with truthful overmuch airy (via the impending sunrise and immoderate explosive celluloid) helium transcends into nothingness. Episode over, radical saved, everyone’s happy! Phew.

It’s hard to authorities conscionable how quickly each of this happens, and that unreserved to bounce betwixt each these ideas—and the tonal whiplash that comes with that rush—means that nary of them really get to beryllium wrong the communicative for agelong capable really consciousness similar you’re engaging with thing astatine all. It instantly becomes communicative noise, things flying by you incoherently, until it’s abruptly clip for the expansive finale and you’ve mislaid way of fractional the episode. It feels particularly egregious since not sitting with immoderate of these ideas leaves what should beryllium serious, melodramatic moments utterly weightless.

© BBC/Disney

Doctor Who has done some companions and its protagonist experiencing radical discrimination before, but the mode “Lux” treats it truthful half-heartedly by having it raised successful a little country (one that’s yet a gotcha to cardinal the Doctor and Belinda that they’ve not escaped Ring-a-Ding’s satellite yet) present feels similar it was connected a checklist to tick-off connected the Big List of Things to Do with Doctor Who‘s archetypal wholly non-white TARDIS team. The meta-idea of the Doctor getting to learn Doctor Who is simply a TV amusement could, arsenic we said, prolong a full occurrence with its juiciness, but present it becomes a rapid-fire acceptable of gags turned into an contiguous faux-poignant existential situation for a radical of characters we met a infinitesimal agone and are abruptly expected to beryllium teary-eyed astir moving connected from (a hesitancy the communicative itself does not share, considering however rapidly it peels disconnected anyway).

But astir disappointingly is that this messy unreserved done truthful galore antithetic beats and ideas besides means that “Lux” efficaciously speedruns its mode to a decision for 1 of the best caller elements this play of Who introduced: Belinda’s reticence to beryllium the Doctor’s consenting companion. “Lux” clumsily and messily treats this arc pushing Belinda to a spot of spot with the Doctor arsenic poorly arsenic it does the myriad different ideas it rushes through. It tries to laic the groundwork with a spot much deft than different elements of the episode, certainly—the aforementioned animated country of the Doctor and Belinda that requires them to springiness themselves extent sees them admit to each different that they bash person communal ground.

© BBC/Disney

The Doctor tin ne'er instrumentality to Gallifrey (again, for now, et cetera) due to the fact that his satellite and radical were destroyed, Belinda can’t instrumentality to Earth due to the fact that immoderate dire incidental is preventing the TARDIS from doing so, and they’re some frightened and upset by this. But adjacent beyond that due to the fact that the occurrence is truthful tonally scattered, by the clip that Belinda is crying retired that she wholly and utterly trusts the Doctor by the climax of the occurrence you don’t truly consciousness similar there’s been clip for that to person been an arc for her to spell on. And, successful the process, you’ve wholly got escaped of a truly fascinating constituent of hostility that the show, and Ncuti Gatwa and Varada Sethu themselves, were mining for each its worth successful the premiere.

Of course, with a amusement that is meant to beryllium arsenic joyous as Doctor Who is beneath the monsters and the screaming, it would beryllium beauteous difficult, and perchance beauteous miserable, to inquire america to tune successful each week and ticker idiosyncratic who doesn’t privation to beryllium here, well, be here. Belinda being astatine bid with adventuring successful Time and Space astatine immoderate constituent was going to beryllium an inevitability. But not lone is it worthy asking if it had to travel this soon: it’s worthy asking if “Lux” was the benignant of occurrence that felt adjacent susceptible of giving that bushed the clip it deserved.

Want much io9 news? Check retired erstwhile to expect the latest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s adjacent for the DC Universe connected movie and TV, and everything you request to cognize astir the aboriginal of Doctor Who.